I am not against promoting your work on Twitter. I am against promo tweets being the majority of what makes up your Twitter feed. This has become the top reason I unfollow authors on Twitter.
Aside from being annoying-- it's like watching a TV show with more running commercials than the program those commercials support-- I don't really see a constant stream of promo tweets as an effective means of marketing.
Because of how Twitter works, it doesn't make sense to me. The only people who are going to see your promo tweets are people who have already taken the step of following you (or retweets, but you can't control that). Meaning, they are already interested in you, or your work, or both. And by that token, they very likely already know that you have books available to buy and where to purchase those books.
If that's the case, then seeing constant advertisements for something you're already aware of, and have already made a decision on whether or not to buy, is extremely irritating.
And before I go any further, there is a difference between hype and promotion (although not in the technical sense). Hype is promotion that takes place before the product is available. This type of promotion doesn't bother me in the slightest, even if it gets heavy. Hype is important to build before a book's release and on the actual release day.
But after that, all the promotion that follows is likened to a commercial. When you continually tweet about your book as if you're still in pre-release hype mode, it's grating. It makes you look self-centered and clueless about online social savvy. And it's borderline insulting to your Twitter followers, as if to say, "Maybe you didn't see it the first million times, but I have this book..."
No. No. A thousand times, NO.
Constant promo tweets also make me think that the author's book isn't doing so well, or as well as they would like (whether that is true or not, I don't know, but that's the impression it gives), so they feel the need to keep talking people into buying it. In that sense, promo tweets have the opposite of their intended effect. A good book sells on word of mouth between readers.
Once your book has released, let the readers sell your book. It's at this point that I expect to see more tweets from the author along the lines of retweeted book reviews. Because if someone else is praising your book I will be more apt to believe it's good.
Of course the author thinks it's good. Of course the author wants you to read it and buy it. So my eyes glaze over when promo comes from the author.
But if someone else recommends the book? I'm much more likely to check it out.
So the question then becomes, "What kind of promotion can an author do post-release that won't irritate his/her followers?" Because there has to be something better than Promo Tweet Vomit.
1. Get involved. Goodreads hosts discussion groups where readers can chat with authors. Amazon has discussion boards. I'm sure B&N does too. These are just a few examples. The main thing to keep in mind here is that you want to go where the readers are, not other writers/authors.
Yes, writers are readers too and writers will make up part of your book-buying audience. So it's not a bad idea to be active on a writers' forum with book links in your signature, but other writers can tell when you're just there to talk about yourself, and it's annoying. Go to the sites for writers to help your fellow writers with their work. Go to the sites for readers to encourage people to read and/or buy your work.
Twitter is a social network. The majority of your Twitter feed should be social, not commercial.
2. Get local. Step away from the Internet and take a stroll to your local library or bookstore (if you're lucky enough to have one). My library hosts Meet the Author type gatherings regularly. Someone who meets you in person is much more likely to buy your book.
And if your book is only available in electronic format, don't fret. Book signings aren't the only thing you can do at bookstores. Ebook-only author events could be a great way for bookstore owners to promote their e-readers.
Do a reading from your Kindle (or whatever you own). You're still showcasing your product-- a great story. We live in the Digital Age. Bookstore appearances do NOT have to center on print book signings anymore.
Also worth considering? Arranging to be interviewed by your local paper. People go nuts over that kind of stuff, they really do. They love having a hometown "celebrity."
3. Get smart. Seek out your target audience. Don't expect them to find you, you go find them. If you write for teens, arrange high school appearances. If you write sci-fi, attend science-related events. If you write women's fiction, start a book club at your house. Etc, etc. Talk to other people who have similar interests as the things you present in your work.
Going back to the example of the local library, you can sign up for programs that don't directly revolve around Author You. My library, which happens to be located right next to the public high school, hosts a monthly book club for YA fiction. It's mainly for the benefit of teen readers, but adults are welcome too (because my library is smart and knows that adults read YA). As a YA writer, I read a lot of YA. I am joining this book club.
If anyone asks why, I can tell them I'm a YA author and let them take it from there. Most people are thrilled to meet authors in person, even if they've never read your work. Just stating this fact about myself usually leads to a discussion about Author Me. But if it doesn't, nothing has been lost and it doesn't come off as annoying promotion because all you did was answer their question.
So those are a few of my ideas. How do YOU feel about constant promo tweets? Can you think of a better way?
~Lydia
Couldn't agree with you more, though I'd also say that retweeting ALL reviews or short compliments about the book also gets annoying. Two, three a day I can take. 20? NO. If you're pleased that someone liked your book, say thank you, send them a few words to show that you care about your readers. Don't just hit a stupid retweet button that takes you all of one second to do. I've unfollowed authors for this reason too. I love your suggestions for getting to know your readers.
ReplyDeleteGood point! Anything that falls under "promotion" should be handled with care. Space out those tweets, and only a certain amount of promo tweets per day. And yes, personalizing your tweets is *always* a good idea.
DeleteI think a lot of people don't understand the "buzz" notion. Unfortunately, it has to be somewhat organic if it's going to work. That is, an author alone really can't create it. It's the readers that get the ball rolling. Contrived buzz feels just that...contrived.
ReplyDeleteVery well said. Thanks, Laurel. :-)
DeleteA well known UK author, Nicola Morgan has put out an ebook Tweet Right that talks about all the etiquette stuff. Her blog is Help!I Need a Publisher! if anyone's interested. As a former journalist I can back up Lydia's claim that newspapers, especially smallish ones, go nuts for local authors. Get your press kit out!
ReplyDeleteThanks for the rec!
DeleteI've unfollowed people on twitter because of constant promotion. I don't mind if people promo their stuff, it's part of what makes twitter so great, but constantly is really irritating.
ReplyDeleteGreat thoughts on how to connect with readers. Libraries are so crucial!
Yes! Go, libraries!
DeleteI'm lucky that I live right in the center of town. The library and high school are literally my next door neighbors. It's wonderful. :-)
Argh, TOTALLY! I was just griping about this on my blog last week (only I called it The Problem With Selling Jesus, because BOY does it remind me of friendly folks ringing my doorbell way too early in the morning.)
ReplyDeleteBut I really like your list of fun and fruitful alternatives, which I will absolutely be saving for my own future use. At the end of the day, I think most of the authors who do this are just feeling the desperate edge, and probably haven't had much practice in selling since the days of Girl Scout Cookies and band candy. This whole online/social thing is a wild frontier, and it's good of you to stop and give friendly directions to the uncomfortable-looking city-people standing around in poison ivy.
I'm not going near any poison ivy! haha.
DeleteThere's definitely an art to this. And for some reason, it doesn't bother me as much when I see agents and editors and publishers tweeting for their authors' books. It's just when the authors do it for themselves... it's all very me-centric, and I've never liked that. Once in a while is fine, but ten times an hour? No thank you.
The problem with Tweeters is they're marketing without knowing what they're doing. There's a tried and true concept in advertising. Annoying potential buyers is NOT one of them.
ReplyDeletethey're marketing without knowing what they're doing.
DeletePrecisely!
I agree. I've unfollowed a few people recently because of relentless promotion that lasts weeks (MONTHS?!) after the book is out. I liked them and their work in the first place, which is why I wanted to follow them, but I just had to do it. Maybe I'll revisit them in the future, who knows.
ReplyDeleteI feel bad whenever I unfollow someone that I liked otherwise. But if they push it far enough then I *have* to do it. For my own sanity.
DeleteThanks for weighing in, Laurie!
This is a great post. I have a page on my blog with my books and where to buy. I share this page on Twitter once or twice a week, but usually closer to once because I never remember. And it's usually every other week, at that. I've been staying away from promoting on Twitter because it's annoying and I'm getting bored with it. There are a lot of other, more productive ways to promote.
ReplyDeleteInteresting! Thanks for sharing your own approach to it. :-)
DeleteGreat post!
ReplyDeleteI know this has always bugged you. I saw you argue with a guy on Twitter about it and he made himself look kind of silly. It's very hard to justify spamming your Twitter followers with advertisements for your own product. The only ones who try to justify it are those who are guilty of it.
ReplyDelete